Skip to content

Best store bought shrimp cocktail sauce

    best store bought shrimp cocktail sauce 2294

    To make this list possible, we have reviewed lots of store-bought shrimp cocktail sauces and compared them by ratings and reviews. Our buying guide should help you decide what kind of product you are looking for. It’s always ideal to purchase products from the best brands, in the end, you get a more quality product for your money’s worth. The reality is you have hundreds if not thousands of store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce products in the same category, and everyone is claiming that their product is the best deal.

    The truth is the cheapest store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce is sometimes better than the most expensive one. The top companies spend lots of money on their advertisement and promotion. That way, the product is as much appealing as possible to you. That’s why following a buyer’s guide is a wise choice. In our list, we made sure we included budget store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce as well as some with a higher price.

    Best store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce – Reviews.

    1. St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce, Extra Spicy Seafood Sauce and...

    St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce, Extra Spicy Seafood Sauce and...
    Our Rating:
    • WORLD FAMOUS SPICY FLAVOR – Fiery. Refreshing. One of a kind. Crafted in a kitchen with 119 years...
    • PACKED WITH HORSERADISH – Made with fresh-ground horseradish root, the dazzling taste of this...
    • PAIRS PERFECTLY WITH SEAFOOD – Notes of citrus keep this sauce light, making it the ideal cocktail...
    • CRAFTED WITH CARE – From our steakhouse to your home kitchen, you can enjoy this iconic St. Elmo...
    • STORAGE – St. Elmo Cocktail Sauce should be stored cold and not left at room temperature longer...

    2. McCormick Golden Dipt Cocktail Sauce for Seafood, 8 fl oz

    McCormick Golden Dipt Cocktail Sauce for Seafood, 8 fl oz
    Our Rating:
    • Cocktail dipping sauce made with real horseradish and hint of lemon
    • Classic sweet and spicy dipping complement to shrimp, oysters, fish and clams
    • Perfect pairing: toss shrimp with white wine and shallots, then dip in sauce
    • Tasty twist: add orange marmalade for a sweet-and-sour sauce, or bake over pork
    • Certified Kosher pareve by the Orthodox Union
    • 8 Ounce

    3. OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce, 8 fl oz

    OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce, 8 fl oz
    Our Rating:
    • Classic tomato and horseradish seafood dipping sauce with OLD BAY zest
    • Featuring our iconic blend of 18 spices and herbs, like celery salt and paprika
    • Big flavor with thick texture and just the right amount of spice
    • The perfect flavor mate for shrimp cocktail, oysters and crab cake sandwiches
    • Ready to eat: just pour and dip, or spoon directly onto food

    4. Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce, 10.5 Ounces (Pack of 3)

    Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce, 10.5 Ounces (Pack of 3)
    Our Rating:

    5. Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

    Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle)
    Our Rating:
    • One 12 oz. bottle of Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce
    • Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce with a great taste that the entire family is sure to love
    • Seafood sauce is great on shrimp, fish and other shellfish
    • Gluten-free seafood cocktail sauce with 0 mg. of cholesterol
    • Tomato concentrate, horseradish, onion powder and garlic powder for a zesty, bold flavor

    6. Premium | Bang Bang Shrimp Sauce | Gluten Free | Low...

    Premium | Bang Bang Shrimp Sauce | Gluten Free | Low...
    Our Rating:
    • DELICIOUS! Now you can make MOUTHWATERING crispy, creamy, sweet and spicy Bang Bang shrimp at home!
    • FAMOUS combination of creamy sweetness, garlic and cayenne. A perfect pairing of mellowed, nutty,...
    • You will not be disappointed. This is our family's 19 year old "TRIED and TRUE" sauce recipe.
    • A double FRESHNESS seal applied to FRESH ingredients immediately after blending for maximum flavor...
    • Buy today and enjoy! The 12 fl. oz. BPA free sturdy bottle comes with a reusable flavor lock screw...

    Sale7. Wilton Armetale Shell Small Sauce/Hors d'Oeuvre

    Wilton Armetale Shell Small Sauce/Hors d'Oeuvre
    Our Rating:
    • Formal to casual, stylish to rustic, each piece we craft is designed to capture the spirit of your...
    • Designed and crafted by hand, these beautiful products were made to last a lifetime.
    • Able to withstand temperatures up to 1000 degrees F, Wilton Armetale Serveware is ideal for your...
    • Hand wash.

    8. McCormick Sauce For Seafood Cocktail Original 8 OZ (Pack of...

    McCormick Sauce For Seafood Cocktail Original 8 OZ (Pack of...
    Our Rating:
    • Kosher.
    • Fresh flavor guarentee
    • America's favorite flavors

    9. Walden Farms Seafood Cocktail Dipping Sauce, 12 oz Bottle,...

    Walden Farms Seafood Cocktail Dipping Sauce, 12 oz Bottle,...
    Our Rating:
    • Classic Seafood Cocktail Sauce – Our dipping sauce is carefully crafted with all-natural,...
    • Fresh, Tangy, and Delicious – Offering the perfect tangy balance to enhance the flavor of your...
    • Craft Tasty Gourmet Recipes – More than a traditional shrimp sauce our seafood dipping sauce pairs...
    • Dairy Free, 0g Net Calorie, Fat-Free Option – This high-quality seafood sauce is crafted with real...
    • Carefully Sealed Freshness – Like our other sauces and marinades, our dipping sauce comes in a...

    10. Stonewall Kitchen New England Cocktail Sauce, 8.25 Ounces

    Stonewall Kitchen New England Cocktail Sauce, 8.25 Ounces
    Our Rating:
    • Stonewall Kitchen New England Cocktail Sauce, 8.25 Ounces
    • What better way to enjoy a fresh shrimp cocktail than with zesty, traditional New England Cocktail...
    • A delicious snap of flavor with horseradish, a little lemon and just the right seasonings
    • Another classic New England recipe
    • It all started in 1991 at a local farmers' market with a few dozen items that we'd finished...

    store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce Buying Guide

    When you want to impress your friends, serve your shrimp cocktail with a tangy, five-ingredient sauce. It can be made in less than 30 minutes and will keep for one to two weeks. The combination of ketchup, spicy horseradish, umami-rich Worcestershire sauce, and sour lemon will make your guests go wild for more. You can even make the cocktail sauce in advance and keep it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks.

    For a quick and easy appetizer, try making the cocktail sauce the night before. It can be prepared up to a week in advance and refrigerated. If you’re cooking the shrimp the day before, you can chill them overnight. It’s best to serve cold, so they’ll stay crisp. This sauce is also great on sandwiches, hot dogs, and vegetables. A couple of tablespoons will do for one pound of shrimp.

    Before serving, make the cocktail sauce. If you want a milder version, simply add a little more sour cream or red pepper flakes. You can also use your favorite seafood marinade. You can also make this sauce ahead of time and refrigerate it for up to a week. However, it’s best to refrigerate it for a couple of days, so it doesn’t lose its flavor.

    To prepare shrimp cocktail sauce, mix together ketchup, chili sauce, and horseradish. Cover and chill until it is time to serve. If you’re serving it cold, you can make the sauce ahead of time and serve it the day before. The sauce can also be served as a zesty dip for non-seafood snacks. The cocktail sauce can be made a day before if you don’t want to chill the shrimp.

    If you want to make a delicious cocktail sauce, make sure you have the right ingredients. It’s important to have a good sauce. The right ingredients will help your shrimp taste great. If you want to add a little spice, use mustard and garlic. Otherwise, add a little salt and pepper to taste. If you’re using lemon, rose extract, make sure it’s fresh. It’s better to add a bit of lemon zest to the sauce to avoid it tasting like old vinegar.

    If you want to make shrimp cocktail sauce, you need to use good quality seasonings. Choose a seasoning salt that has no artificial flavors or colors. It should have a high sugar content and should be gluten-free as well. A seasoning salt that has a high salt content is not healthy. Hence, you should use an all-natural cocktail sauce to make your shrimp taste great. It can also be used as a substitute for lemon juice.

    There are many different kinds of cocktail sauces, which are a great option for those who love to experiment with different flavors. There are many brands out there, so you should make sure that you select a brand that’s popular and has a lot of good reviews. A great cocktail sauce can be used with many kinds of dishes. You can even use it in Bloody Marys and deviled eggs. To make a perfect cocktail sauce, you should start by blending the right ingredients.

    When it comes to shrimp cocktail sauce, you need to make it as thick as possible. A thicker sauce can cause your shrimp to swell and will be overcooked. A good sauce can also be used for dipping any kind of seafood. You can use it for a variety of foods, including seafood. You can use it as a dipping sauce or serve it as a condiment with your favorite foods. You can use this delicious sauce on shrimp or as a dipping sauce for any other type of seafood.

    Once you’ve chosen the sauce, you’ll need to buy shrimp. At grocery stores, you can buy shell-on or tail-on shrimp. If you’re serving your guests, make sure to buy large tail-on shrimp, as they look the best and are easiest to eat. If you’re planning to serve shrimp to a crowd, serve it with cocktail sauce. If you’re looking for a delicious sauce, it’s worth the extra effort.

    store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce Buying Checklist

    Ingredient list: You’ve got to pay attention to the ingredient list. Some ingredients are more harmful than others.

    Materials: The same goes for the material. Some are harmful, while other companies focus on a safer store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce product and aim for more satisfied customers.

    Storing and maintenance: Storing and maintenance of the store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce the right way is important. Make sure to research how to store and maintain your product so the quality remains high for a long time.

    Shelf life: Check the shelf life of the product. If buying appliances, make sure that the items are durable so you can use them for years.

    Functionality: Get to know the functions of each product and learn how to use it. Check that there are no additional functions you don’t need because you will pay less for the store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce if they don’t.

    Brand recognition: Buy from a reputable brand. It will increase the chance that the store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce is made of quality.

    Need or want: Decide if you need the store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce or you just want it. In the end, the product may have no significant value to you, and it will just collect dust.

    Calculate the cost: In advance, calculate the costs and think if it fits in your budget.

    Can you make it yourself: If you have spare time, some products might be cheaper if you make them yourself. Buying the materials and making them yourself might even be enjoyable.

    Take a break: Before making the final decision, take a 30-minute break and rethink the value the store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce will give you and how it will affect your budget.

    What the effect will be: Give a thought if the product has an impact on your life in other areas. Sometimes we think we need something badly. Then we find out it negatively affected other areas of our life.

    Peer pressure: It is wise not to purchase something just because your friend has it and it looks cool. It may lead to disappointment when you find out it is not as good as your friend showed you.

    Train restraint: If you are on a tight budget and don’t need the product right away, wait for a couple of days and decide then.


    We hope we helped you out and you have a better idea of which store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce is best for you. If you are on a tight budget, don’t forget to check out the products that are the least expensive. Keep in mind that they are still very usable and worth purchasing because they are highly reviewed and liked by customers.

    However, if you are looking for more high-end products, we are certain that you will be satisfied with the more pricey store-bought shrimp cocktail sauce because customer satisfaction speaks for itself. We review a lot of food-related products and if you got some spare time, feel free to navigate to our main page, where you can find more top 10 best lists.